Status:Closed    Asked:Sep 21, 2017 - 12:35 AM

Are birthplace variables spatially harmonized?

Do you have the same question? Follow this Question

Staff Answer


Jeff Bloem


Although the BPL variable provides similar information for all years, the presence of shifting political boundaries and an increasingly diverse population requires more inclusive classification schemes in more recent years. There is nothing done to the birthplace variable that ensures spatial comparability over time as the birthplace variable reports the self-reported birthplace of the respondent within the sample year. More specific notes about comparability issues can be found on the Comparability Tab.


Sep 21, 2017 - 09:58 AM

Report it

Voted Best Answer

This is a great question! We will continue our spatial harmonization work in coming years, extending it next to migration variables and finally to birthplace variables. Birthplace will be the most difficult since it covers the longest temporal span of any geography variables. The shifting political boundaries, mentioned in the documentation and by Jeff in the previous reply, are especially pronounced for the BPL variable(s).


Sep 21, 2017 - 10:46 AM

Report it


Thank you so much Jeff and Lara!

I was really hoping your answer to be yes hahaha. But yes, trying to do it by myself for a couple countries made me aware of the difficulties. Again, thank you for your help!


Sep 21, 2017 - 02:44 PM

Report it

Ohh one more question.

If the variable is just reporting self-reported birthplace, this could correspond to administrative units either at the time of birth or at the time of the survey right?

Or is some correction in place in case the respondent reports an administrative unit that shifted boundaries (so as to move his birthplace somewhere else) or that doesn't exist anymore?


Sep 21, 2017 - 03:05 PM

Report it


Reason for missing MIGSTA1 values in ASEC files for 1985 (and 1995)
India Area-level data (geo2) inconsistent for total population, urban share, ...
Does anyone have a method for handling missing data in CPS "EDUC" variable? 2...
How do I find the data file:Ipumsi_00001.dat for the 1974
Variables from Full Year Consolidated Files currently not included in IPUMS-M...
Wrong HH weight Tanzania 2012 census?
Login   |   Register

Recently Active Members

View More »

Share |