Question

Status:Closed    Asked:Nov 28, 2016 - 01:57 PM

FERTYR/YNGCH disagreement

When i crosstab FERTYR*YNGCH for women ages 15-50, I find about 1900 cases in the 2015 ACS where a woman reports a yngch>1 in the home, but FERTYR NE 2.


I know some small share of these might be cases where the infant is adopted so the coding is OK, but looking through the HH records, that doesn't seem to be that common.


Can you give me any advice about how I can get this coding to match up appropriately? There are many cases where it seems pretty clear that FERTYR should probably=2, but some cases are less obvious, so I hesitate to implement a global edit.


Thanks for any help,

Gretchen

 
Do you have the same question? Follow this Question
 

Staff Answer

avatar

Joe_Grover

Staff

There are a few things to consider when comparing FERTYR and YNGCH. First, FERTYR represents a direct response to a Questionnaire item while YNGCH is constructed by IPUMS-USA based on Family Interrelationship linking. Since the family interrelationship linking methodology was developed for use with the Decennial Censuses, FERTYR is not considered in the construction of MOMLOC, so it is possible that IPUMS-USA is incorrectly identifying mothers of newborns in some of these households. It is also worth mentioning that the Census Bureau does allocate this variable if it is missing. You can identify allocated values with the QFERTYR.

Unfortunately, I cannot provide a simple solution for when to assume that the FERTYR value or the YNGCH value is more accurate. You may wish to privileged un-allocated FERTYR values since they represent direct responses. But if YNGCH and FERTYR conflict and FERTYR was allocated, it may be worth while to take a closer look at the household and see which case seems more logical.

I hope this helps.

 

Nov 29, 2016 - 02:31 PM

1
0
Report it

OTHER QUESTIONS NEEDING ANSWERS

Merging NBER and IPUMS ASEC data for 1962-1967 surveys
For the Higher Ed dataset of all the observations the salary is at most $150,...
Is it appropriate to use cluster and strata for person weighting?
In IPUMS MEPS, how was the variable OPNPVIS derived? What MEPS variables were...
In IPUMS MEPS, how was the variable OBNPVIS derived? What MEPS variables did ...
Can you please let me know if the following criteria seems correct to identif...
Login   |   Register

Recently Active Members

View More »

Share |