Question

Status:Closed    Asked:Nov 16, 2018 - 09:31 AM

PUMA codes assigned to all states [ACS 2012 and 2013 (1% sample)]

Hi all,


I found that there are a number of PUMA codes in the ACS (100, 101, ...) that are assigned to ALL states. In other words, I have various households (serial) in all U.S. states assigned to the PUMA code 100 (and 101 etc.)--this odd duplication of PUMAs is the case for a significant portion of my data set.

(I am aware that PUMAs are not unique. It is of course fine that certain PUMAs are assigned to two areas in different states.)

Is there something wrong with my data set? Is there a special significance to certain PUMA codes (i.e. 100)?


Thank you in advance.



 
Do you have the same question? Follow this Question
 

Voted Best Answer

As noted on the codes tab of the PUMA variable, PUMA codes are state dependent. Therefore, they must be interpreted in combination with a state id variable.

 

Nov 16, 2018 - 09:59 AM

1
0
Report it

Answers

There is nothing special about PUMA codes one way or the other. The Census Bureau makes some moderate attempt to keep PUMA numbers consistent year to year, but the ultimate fact that PUMA numbers overlap between state is of utmost annoyance to the users. And no, that won't change in 2020 Census -- I'd be stunned if it did.


What I usually do is


generate long unique_PUMA = st*1e5 + puma


so that I can see both the state and the PUMA number in that combined ID. I think in some of the Census products, you do see the PUMAs thus appended together, as well... maybe with a dot between them or something.



 

Nov 16, 2018 - 09:36 AM

1
0
Report it

Thanks for this reply. I'm not sure what I'm experiencing is just that though. My data looks like this--covering about 1/3 of all households. (I'm sorry about the formatting--should all be columns.) I cannot believe that this is right? It renders PUMAs almost entirely useless.

puma state

100 colorado

100 oklahoma

100 tennesse

100 iowa

100 missouri

100 massachu

100 ... all states 101 connecti 101 californ 101 californ 101 florida 101 californ 101 ... all states . . . 1400 iowa 1400 missouri 1400 indiana 1400 maryland 1400 south ca 1400 missis 1400 ... all states

 

Nov 16, 2018 - 09:43 AM

0
0
Report it

alright then--thank you both!

 

Nov 16, 2018 - 10:01 AM

0
0
Report it

OTHER QUESTIONS NEEDING ANSWERS

ACS 2012 5% and PUMA codes
2014 ACS Migration PUMA: San Francisco Codes Confusion
1990 1% PUMA boundaries file when using 1990 1% unweighted IPUMS USA data?
Health Insurance Unit in ACS versus MEPS
Login   |   Register

Recently Active Members

View More »

Share |